Before I get started though, quick bit of house keeping - I've now got an account on Linked in. I'll be using it as a professional e-networking tool and a way of connecting.
The Final Countdown
Firstly I'll respond to a blog post by Sam Lyons - a wonderful post about his journey as a Slalom Canoe racer entitled "The Final Countdown". One of the first things that grabbed me was the coming to terms with some of the realities of life, in terms of goals that can't always be reached. I can remember being a young and naive football (soccer) player and thinking "Well, if I don't make it to Arsenal, I'll just play for some second division German team or something.." - not to say in any way that Sam was naive in his goal to be an Olympic champion. As I got older I realised how absurd that assumption was and the finite number of players that actually make it as professionals. I see the same thing now in my work with the AIS football team. These 15-16 year old boys have been identified as some of the most talented young players in the country, and the reality is not all of them will make it - it's a harsh reality given the commitment that they have to the sport. This raises the expectations of the coach to bring the best out of these players and give them the best chance of succeeding. The second thing that got me was the mention of the adversities he has faced in the form of injuries. Once again it is something I can relate to as when I was 16, moving up to the level of a more serious U/18 Premier league competition I suffered a torn hamstring. I was out for most of that U/16 season and the following year my leg was broken. It was hard to recover from these injuries psychologically as much as physically - getting back into it I found I couldn't play at the same level I could previously, and I found myself hating playing a sport I had lived and breathed for the majority of my life. It took me a while to change my thinking into "Well, football will always be there, it's not going anywhere, I can spend the next few years just focusing on my studies and try to further myself to the point where I can have a job in the sport". I think it's important for athletes to succeed on an educational/career path as much sport due to the number of things that could take professional sport away in the blink of an eye. The last thing that I found very interesting was that one of his biggest highlights was his sisters promotion into Division 3. My older brother is the main reason I got into football. One of my highlights was being able to play in the same team as him only a couple of years ago. We truly are a product of our environment - the more I think about it the more I realise how much he has had an effect on me, from the music I listen to, to my determination to succeed in what I do, as he has done.
I think that the "product of our environment" philosophy can be directly related to coaching - in both the way we coach, and the way that this translates to the resultant effect we have on our athletes.
The Coach as a Performer
In week 4 we turned our focus to the coach as a performer. This includes relating coach performance to being just as important and often accountable for athlete performance as well as styles of coaching/teaching.
Starting off lightly, here's a bit of a satirical take on different types of sports coaches, although to be honest, they aren't far off with some.
Here however is a slightly more academic approach by Theresa Echtermeyer from the National Soccer Coaches Association of America on Coaching Styles and How They Impact Player Development. Echtermeyer outlines 3 styles of coaching.
1. The Authoritarian (aka Commander/Dictator) - An outcome based approach where the athlete's role is to respond to the coach's commands. We saw a clear example of this in Nikolay Karpol the Russian volleyball coach.
2. The Casual Coach (aka Submissive/Babysitter) - An approach where the coach takes a back seat and lets the players make all the decisions. Often used by less experienced coach's or in instances where the outcome is of lesser importance.
3. The Cooperative coach (aka Democrat/Teacher) - An athlete centred approach where the coach facilitates and the athlete is encouraged to participate in the decision making.
Each approach has varying advantages and disadvantages, and at the end of the day, each approach can lead to successful athlete performance - both in process and in outcome. A classmate of mine - Trent Hopkinson further discusses this in Coaching Approaches blog.
Another of my classmates - Leigh Sherman also shared some interesting thoughts on the dynamic nature of coaches and the requirement to get the best out of each individual in a team in his Are Players the only Performers in Sport? blog.
If I relate this back to my own experiences with the AIS football team - I've observed that the coaches are often more vocal in terms of direction during matches than the opposition coaches. A common difference between the AIS team compared to opposition teams is that the majority of the AIS athletes are 15-16, whereas opposition athletes are on average 19-20 and often older. I think that given the athletes age and their introduction to the National Youth League (a far different game to what they're often used to) that more direction and instruction is necessary. I believe that in usual club circumstances, the athletes should receive enough direction and coaching during training sessions that during a match the instruction to players should be limited to pre match prep and half time talks - with the odd instruction here and there. I feel this way because I think the athletes at that level should by then have a pretty good indication of their role and be able to self-adapt to changing circumstances - if they don't, I think the coach hasn't done their job.
Week 4 Tutorial
In our most recent tutorial, we all joined in on some basketball fun. Keith took us through a session which involved easy ways of forming groups, different ways to communicate, useful methods of modifying simple games into sports and monitoring participant performance/enjoyment. It reminded me a lot of the Active After-school Communities program initiative by the Australian Sports Commission which is intended to provide primary school aged children access to free sport and other structured physical activity. I think it is an essential course for anyone intending to work with children or even just coaching in general. They offer a whole range of tools and resources as well as support.
And the final whistle blows..
Hi Aidan,
ReplyDeleteFirstly thanks for the plug of my blog!
Reading you post for this week and hearing your thoughts on the pipe dreams of young players got me thinking about how important coaches are to aspiring players and how a bad coach could kill off a career before it even begins!
I think your point adds to my argument over the diversity of a coaches role, not only are they expected to perform but their actions, especially when dealing with the elite youth, have some pretty strong flow on effects.
Perhaps these coaches deserve bigger salaries than the players (Josh Dugan)?
Aidan,
ReplyDeleteFirstly let me say what a marathon it was to read your blog!!! but saying that you made every word count.
I like how you have related your experiences in the sport, to that of Sam Lyon and different styles coaches.
going on from LeighTS comment on perhaps coaches deserving bigger salaries than players. It would be interesting to see what type of money a coach gets in comparsion to the players. Went you take into account that they take care of 20 or more players and staff in terms of tactics and prepartion and that the perform of the team comes back directly on them rather than the players on most occasions. I think i may discuss this in my next post thanks for the idea Leigh!
Hi Aidan,
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to say I rely enjoyed your article and the way you put forward the traditional academic approach to coaching styles really made me sit back and think about what makes a good coach and how it relates to my own personal development. In my most recent post I have started to reflect on this and whether or not some of these more 'traditional' approaches are obselte and put a link through to your post so feel free to check it out. Though it is a bit of a novel and mish mash of my own thoughts on the subject. Really looking forward to reading more from you.
Sarah
Thanks Sarah!
DeleteI've had a read and also put some of my own thoughts down :)
Aidan
ReplyDeleteWhat an enjoyable, thought-provoking blog post. I like the style of your writing and the ways you share insights. Thanks for sharing your reflections.
Best wishes
Keith